In Watching China Watching we offer essays and reflections on studying the Chinese world and approaches to understanding the Chinese People’s Republic. Our method is underpinned by New Sinology.
The men and women who taught us to engage with the Chinese world and to appreciate things Chinese in a holistic fashion were motivated and inspired by many things: their personal histories, a diverse range of interests, as well as a pressing necessity to watch (and to watch out for) China. For many of them, Chinese and non-Chinese alike (after all, some of the greatest China Watchers are from China), China was not a distant subject for study but an essential part of lived reality. Their insights were generally based not on some crude social science or anthropological approach to observing The Other, or the result of dissecting an object rich in possibility as part of some ambitious career trajectory. Their understanding was based as much on entanglement, fraught questioning, a spirit of self-discovery and personal enrichment as the result of a lifelong effort to approach what is in fact an all-encompassing cultural-political world from a broad humanistic perspective.
***
An intellectual is someone whose mind watches itself. I like this, because I am happy to be both halves, the watcher and the watched.
— Albert Camus
***
We are interested in the professional China Watchers, a once nearly-defunct claque of people working in government for national political ends, journalists, academics, ne’er-do-wells, as well as the talented curious and literary dilettantes. In the ‘New Epoch’ of Chairman of Everything Xi Jinping, the long-overlooked, or underestimated, skills of being able to read, listen to and understand the bloviations of the Chinese party-state are, perhaps, in vogue once more.
In producing Watching China Watching we also want to leave some material from the past for those who are engaged with the Chinese multiverse and who would watch, learn, imbue and develop their own approach to China and its world as part of their personal human struggle in what is a world of contentious ideas, ideological fabrications, conflicted interests and strained emotions.
For more on the topic of ‘The China Expert’ 中國通, or ‘Old China Hand’, see my introduction to Jao Tsung-I on 通 tōng — 饒宗頤與通人, China Heritage, 23 June 2017.
— Geremie R. Barmé
Editor, China Heritage
5 January 2018
Watching China Watching
- The China Expert and The Ten Commandments — Watching China Watching (I), China Heritage, 5 January 2018
- Non-existent Inscriptions, Invisible Ink, Blank Pages — Watching China Watching (II), China Heritage, 7 January 2018
- On New China Newspeak 新華文體 — Watching China Watching (III), China Heritage, 9 January 2018
- The Tradition of China Watching — Watching China Watching (IV), China Heritage, 11 January 2018
- Morrison of Peking — Watching China Watching (V), China Heritage, 13 January 2018
- Diplomats, Scholars, Adventurers — Watching China Watching (VI), China Heritage, 15 January 2018
- White Paper, Red Menace — Watching China Watching (VII), China Heritage, 17 January 2018
- Assignment: China — Watching China Watching (VIII), China Heritage, 19 January 2018
- China 1976: An Ambassador’s Advice — Watching China Watching (IX), China Heritage, 21 January 2018
- Peking Duck Soup — Watching China Watching (X), China Heritage, 23 January 2018
- I’m So Ronree — Watching China Watching (XI), China Heritage, 25 January 2018
- For Truly Great Men, Look to This Age Alone — Watching China Watching (XII), China Heritage, 27 January 2018
- On the Eve — Watching China Watching (XIII), China Heritage, 29 January 2018
- The Man With the Key — Watching China Watching (XIV), China Heritage, 31 January 2018
- Conflicting Caricatures — Watching China Watching (XV), China Heritage, 2 February 2018
- Peking Tom — Watching China Watching (XVI), China Heritage, 4 February 2018
- An Ultrastable System — Watching China Watching (XVII), China Heritage, 6 February 2018
- Saying the Unsayable — Watching China Watching (XVIII), China Heritage, 8 February 2018
- Watching & Warning — Watching China Watching (XIX), China Heritage, 10 February 2018
- Eugenio Menegon, The Christian Conundrum of Yongzheng — Watching China Watching (XX), China Heritage, 13 April 2018
- Contentious Friendship — Watching China Watching (XXI), China Heritage, 29 April 2018
- May Fourth at Ninety-nine — Watching China Watching (XXII), China Heritage, 4 May 2018
- Eugenio Menegon, Render Unto the Emperor — Watching China Watching (XXIII), China Heritage, 7 May 2018
- The Possible and the Probable — Watching China Watching (XXIV), China Heritage, 21 May 2018
- Something In The Air — Watching China Watching (XXV), China Heritage, 8 June 2018
- Geremie R. Barmé, One Decent Man, The New York Review of Books, 28 June 2018, vol.64, no.11 — Watching China Watching (XXVI)
- China Digital Times, Resistance and the Ethical China Watcher — Watching China Watching (XXVII), China Heritage, 22 June 2018
- David Brophy, The Borderlands of a Brave New World — Watching China Watching (XXVIII), China Heritage, 26 June 2018
- Geremie R. Barmé, Mendacious, Hyperbolic & Fatuous — an ill wind from People’s Daily — Watching China Watching (XXIX), China Heritage, 10 July 2018
- Geremie R. Barmé, Silent China & Its Enemies — Watching China Watching (XXX), China Heritage, 13 July 2018
- Geremie R. Barmé & Lee Yee, Deathwatch for a Chairman, China Heritage, 17 July 2018 (The Best China XIII and Watching China Watching XXXI)
- Geremie R. Barmé, A People’s Banana Republic, China Heritage, 5 September 2018, also published as Peak Xi Jinping?, ChinaFile, 4 September 2018 (Watching China Watching XXXII)
- Ian Johnson, China Watching — Language Wars, from Montreal to Beijing — Watching China Watching (XXXIII), China Heritage, 12 October 2018
- Alice L. Miller, Analysing the Chinese Leadership in an Era of Sex, Money and Power — Watching China Watching (XXXIV), China Heritage, 3 November 2018
- Robert Conquest, The Kremlin Then, Zhongnanhai Now — Watching China Watching (XXXV), China Heritage, 18 December 2018
- Charles Parton, China Watching — old skills honed for a ‘new era’ — Watching China Watching (XXXVI), China Heritage, 24 August 2022
- Steve Tsang, Minting China Strategies in the United Kingdom — Watching China Watching (XXXVII), China Heritage, 26 August 2022
- Brian Moloughney, Sinology vs. the Disciplines, Then & Now — Watching China Watching (XXXVIII), China Heritage, 24 September 2022
- Kathrin Hille, China Watching in the Xi Jinping Era of Blindness and Deafness — Watching China Watching (XXXIX), China Heritage, 28 September 2022
- Geremie R. Barmé, China’s Highly Consequential Political Silly Season: Part I; Part II; and, Part III, China Heritage, October 2022
- You Can Get Here from There — Soviet historian Stephen Kotkin on Xi Jinping’s China — Watching China Watching (XL), China Heritage, 9 May 2023
- Robert Barnett, Communist Chinese Mantras — keywords and the importance of formulaic language — Watching China Watching (XLI), China Heritage, 8 June 2023
- ‘Read, read, read. Listen, listen, listen.’ — It’s Never Too Late to Learn Modern and Literary Chinese, China Heritage, 19 July 2023
- Eating watermelon with Wu Guoguang — a summer seminar in China watching, The China Project, 1 August 2023
- Voices from The Other China — Ten Podcasts & Twenty YouTube Channels, 10 August 2023
- Ukraine Watching China Watching Ukraine, 22 August 2023
- Lessons from the black box of Chinese politics, The China Project, 3 October 2023
- Humanism, a Modest Existential Threat to Xi Jinping’s Ideological Security State — 人妖之間, 20 October 2023
- How secure is Xi Jinping’s rule?, Britain’s World, 10 November 2023
- Li Keqiang, the ‘Empty Boat’ of the Xi Jinping Era, 14 November 2023
- Charles Parton, Drongos and D-words, 29 December 2023
- Professor Graham ‘Thucydides Trap’ Allison’s Three-Body Problem, 28 March 2024
- You are garlic chives!’ — Trisolarans, Burn Book and China’s Men in Black, 20 April 2024
- May Fourth at 105 — Protest, Resistance, Repression, 1 May 2024; May Fourth at Seventy, 4 May 2024; Captive Minds & Academic Angst on May Fourth 2024, 8 May 2024
- Robert Bosch, Whispering advice, roaring praises: The role of Chinese think tanks under Xi Jinping, Merics, 8 May 2024
- Michael Szonyi, The Ming dynasty, research work in China today and the US-China relationship, 4 July 2024
- Geremie R. Barmé and Simon Leys, Recalling an Expert ‘China Expert’, 11 August 2024
- To Go or Not to Go — Jeffrey N. Wasserstrom on his China Conundrum, 12 September 2024
- Simon Leys, et al, Han Suyin and Two-faced People, 26 September 2024
Supplementary Material:
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘Supping with a Long Spoon — dinner with Premier Li, November 1988’, China Heritage, 10 December 2018
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘China Blames the West for “Cultural Pollution” ’, The National Times, January 1984; reprinted online under the titled ‘Spiritual Pollution Thirty Years On’, The China Story Journal, 17 November 2013 and, again, in China Heritage
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘The Good Caucasian of Sichuan & Kumbaya China’, China Heritage, 1 September 2020
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘Beijing Days, Beijing Nights, May 1989’, China Heritage, 4 June 2021
- Isaiah Berlin, et al, ‘Xi Jinping’s China & Stalin’s Artificial Dialectic’, China Heritage, 10 June 2021
- Lee Yee 李怡, ‘Apple Daily, ‘The Four Noes’ & the End of Chinese Media Independence’, China Heritage, 24 June 2021
- Geremie R. Barmé, A.M. Rosenthal, et al, ‘Beijing, 1st July 2021 — ‘It was a sunny day and the trees were green…’, China Heritage, 1 July 2021
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘Red Allure & The Crimson Blindfold’, China Heritage, 13 July 2021
- ‘In Memoriam — Pierre Ryckmans (Simon Leys)’, China Heritage, 11 August 2021
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘The Fog of Words: Kabul 2021, Beijing 1949’, SupChina, 24 August 2021
- Simon Leys, ‘Two Plus Two Equals Five—China’s New Math’, China Heritage, 8 September 2021
- Geremie R. Barmé, ‘Prelude to a Restoration: Xi Jinping, Deng Xiaoping, Chen Yun & the Spectre of Mao Zedong’, China Heritage, 20 September 2021
Related Material:
- Jao Tsung-I on 通 tōng — 饒宗頤與通人, China Heritage, 23 June 2017
- Cutting a Deal with China, China Heritage, 20 July 2017
- The Battle Behind the Front, China Heritage, 25 September 2017
- The Best China, China Heritage, 1 October 2017-
- Colin Mackerras, Sinophiles and Sinophobes: Western Views of China, Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, 2000